7 Ways John Deere’s X580 Has Given Us Problems

The John Deere X580 lawn tractor, part of the X500 series, and manufactured in 2016, is recognized for its potent 24-horsepower Kawasaki engine, hydrostatic transmission, and a 54-inch cutting deck among other features. With a notable weight of 636 lbs and a wheelbase of 51.2 inches, it embodies the combination of power and agility, making it ideal for a range of gardening tasks including mowing, snow blowing, and more. It was priced at $7,299 in 2017, showcasing its position in a higher price bracket due to its enhanced capabilities.

Common problems associated with this lawn tractor range from engine starting failure, engine stalling, or rough running, to imperfect cutting, and abnormal heating among others. Notable issues include malfunctioning spark plugs, throttle cables, or even clogged fuel systems that might hinder the seamless operation of the mower.

The discourse around these problems is vital whether you are contemplating purchasing the X580 or are an existing owner facing some operational challenges. The ability to identify, troubleshoot, and resolve these issues can significantly enhance the longevity and performance of your lawn tractor, ensuring that your investment continues to provide value over time. Now, let’s delve into the 7 most common problems, analyze the underlying causes, and explore the troubleshooting steps to get your mower back in top-notch condition.

Igra-World, with its substantial experience in the lawn care industry and a rich history of interaction with gardening enthusiasts, has accumulated a wealth of knowledge on common tractor woes. Our technicians, with a combined experience of over X years, frequently encounter queries regarding JD’s X580, mirroring the experiences shared by our community of lawn care aficionados. As one satisfied customer, Mr. Green, aptly put it, “Igra-World’s insights into tackling the starting failure on my X580 were a game-changer, it saved me a pricey trip to the repair shop!”

How to troubleshoot the most common issues:

Engine Starting Failure (severity: high): Check and refill fuel levels, clean or replace spark plugs, inspect spark plug wires, and ensure the brake pedal is depressed before starting.

Engine Stalls or Runs Rough (severity: medium): Inspect the ignition system including the ignition coil, flywheel, and kill switch. Adjust the throttle cable and ensure it’s properly lubricated.

Imperfect Cutting (severity: low): Sharpen or replace blades, adjust the cutting deck height, and moderate your cutting speed.

Abnormal Heating (severity: medium): Avoid overloading, check and refill engine oil, and adjust the idle setting to the proper level.

Malfunctioning Drive Belt (severity: medium): Ensure the tension level is adequate, replace a worn-out belt.

Fuel Gauge Malfunction* (severity: low): Check for electrical issues or replace the fuel gauge if necessary (hypothetical).

Difficulty in Steering* (severity: medium): Inspect and lubricate steering components, and replace any worn-out parts (hypothetical).

The Engine is Performing Poorly

1. Engine Starting Failure

The most common issues causing engine starting failure in the lawn tractor are a depleted fuel tank, faulty or dirty spark plugs, a dead battery, or a clogged fuel filter.

Engine starting failure can be a real setback, especially when there’s a large lawn waiting to be mowed. This issue often roots from several mechanical hitches. A common culprit is the fuel level—your mower’s engine won’t even stutter if the gasoline tank is empty. Besides, the quality of gasoline plays a crucial role; using old or incorrect grade fuel can harm your engine or clog the fuel system—a regular mishap many owners face. The spark plug, a small yet indispensable component, might also be at fault. A dirty or worn-out spark plug can prevent the engine from starting. Additionally, your tractor’s battery condition is pivotal. A dead battery or loosely connected cables can halt the engine from starting up, making it imperative to ensure it’s fully charged and the connections are secure.

The specifications of the lawn tractor hint at its robustness and efficiency with a 24HP Kawasaki 726cc 2-cyl gasoline engine, and a fuel tank capacity of 4.4 gallons. The tractor’s hydrostatic transmission, electrical system with a 12-volt battery, and power steering are engineered for smooth operations, but a hiccup in any of these systems can lead to engine starting failure. Your endeavors to troubleshoot should hence be meticulous to ensure you’re not missing out on any detail that could be the cause of the problem.

How to Fix Engine Starting Failure:

  1. Check Fuel Level: Ensure the fuel tank has enough gasoline. Refill if necessary.
  2. Inspect Spark Plugs: Clean or replace spark plugs if they appear dirty or worn out.
  3. Battery Check: Ensure the battery is fully charged and cables are securely connected.
  4. Fuel Filter Inspection: Check the fuel filter for clogs and clean or replace it if necessary.
  5. Depress Brake Pedal: Before attempting to start, ensure the brake pedal is depressed.
  6. Check Electrical Connections: Ensure all electrical connections are secure and free of corrosion.
  7. Consult a Technician: If the problem persists, consider consulting a John Deere technician for a thorough inspection and repair.

2. Engine Stalls or Runs Rough

The most common culprits causing engine stalling or rough running are faulty fuel lines, a dirty carburetor, worn-out spark plugs, and inadequate fuel supply. Issues like contaminated or poor-quality gas can also lead to this issue.

Boasting a 24HP Kawasaki 726cc 2-cyl gasoline engine and a hydrostatic transmission, this tractor is a robust lawn tractor designed for various lawn maintenance tasks. Despite its mechanical prowess, it’s prone to engine stalling or rough running under certain conditions, mainly due to inconsistent engine maintenance. Faulty fuel lines are often the primary cause behind this frustrating situation, manifesting either as an empty gas tank, a defective fuel pump, or a clogged fuel line. Poor fuel quality or contaminated gas can exacerbate this problem. A dirty carburetor and worn-out spark plugs are other significant contributors to this issue. When driving uphill, the fuel struggles to reach the engine, potentially leading to stalling. The symptoms of a faulty or dirty carburetor include hard starts, emission of black smoke, and rough driving. Overused spark plugs can result in rough idle, stalling, excess fuel consumption, and deposits on cylinder heads—addressing these issues is crucial to ensure the lawn tractor operates efficiently and to prevent any potential damage to the engine or other essential components.

How to Fix Engine Stalls or Runs Rough:

  1. Inspect the fuel system: Check if there’s adequate fuel in the tank, and ensure it’s of high quality and free from contaminants.
  2. Flush the fuel line: Especially if you’ve used substandard or dirty gas, flushing helps deal with clogs in the line.
  3. Address fuel pump issues: Fix a faulty pump, or replace it if necessary.
  4. Clean or replace the carburetor: If the carburetor is dirty or faulty—indicated by hard starts, black smoke emission, and rough driving—disassemble it, clean it with a cleaner like WD-40, and replace any broken parts.
  5. Replace spark plugs: If they are overused, replacing them with top-grade ones can alleviate the problem.
  6. Adjust your mowing path: When mowing uphill, choose alternative paths to prevent stalling, ensuring a functionally sound fuel pump to work on sloped landscapes without trouble.

3. Imperfect Cutting

The most common issues causing imperfect cutting are dull or damaged blades, incorrect cutting deck height, and excessive cutting speed.

Imperfect cutting is a problem that often surfaces after periods of frequent use. When you notice uneven cuts or missed spots on your lawn, it’s usually a signal to inspect the cutting blades—they could be dull or damaged and may require sharpening or replacing. Additionally, the height of the cutting deck might be set incorrectly, leading to unevenness in the cut. The mower’s speed while cutting also plays a vital role—the faster the speed, the higher the likelihood of missing spots or achieving uneven cuts. The specifications such as its 24HP Kawasaki engine and hydrostatic transmission, ensure smooth operations, but the mechanical aspects like blades and cutting deck height are crucial for a perfect cut. The 48″ or 54″ mid-mount mower deck is designed for efficient cutting, but the blades’ condition and correct deck height are imperative for optimal performance. Imperfect cutting not only affects the lawn’s appearance but could also lead to other challenges, such as increased wear on the lawn tractor and inefficient fuel usage. The mechanical simplicity—like the two-wheel drive and mechanical rear differential lock—of the X580 doesn’t exempt it from the basic maintenance needs that significantly impact the cutting quality.

How to Fix Imperfect Cutting:

  1. Inspect the blades: Check blades for sharpness and damage. If they are dull or damaged, sharpen or replace them.
  2. Check the cutting deck height: Adjust it to the recommended level for your lawn type and condition.
  3. Moderate your cutting speed: If you’ve been mowing at high speed, reduce it to allow for a more precise cut.
  4. Consider the terrain you are mowing: Adjust your speed and deck height accordingly to achieve a more uniform cut.

4. Abnormal Heating

The most common causes of abnormal heating in the excessive overloading of the engine, decreased engine oil, and incorrect idle setting adjustments.

Abnormal heating primarily emanates from three core issues. First, the robust 24HP Kawasaki 726cc 2-cyl gasoline engine is designed to tolerate some level of overloading, but excessive overloading can cause the engine to overheat. This is often a result of utilizing attachments that demand high power, such as the 48″ or 54″ mid-mount mower decks, beyond the tractor’s capacity—pushing the engine beyond its limit increases the internal temperature, leading to overheating. Second, engine oil plays a crucial role in lubricating engine components, reducing friction, and subsequently, the engine’s temperature. A decrease in engine oil levels can cause friction among engine parts, escalating the engine’s temperature rapidly. It’s essential to maintain the recommended engine oil level to ensure smooth operation. Lastly, the idle setting adjustment is vital for controlling the engine’s temperature. An incorrect idle setting can result in the engine running at higher speeds than necessary, causing it to overheat. Adjusting the idle setting to the proper level ensures the engine operates within a safe temperature range, promoting longevity and efficient performance of your lawn tractor.

How to Fix Abnormal Heating:

  1. Reduce Engine Load: Ensure that you are not overloading the engine—remove any unnecessary attachments and adhere to the recommended operating guidelines for your attachments.
  2. Check and Refill Engine Oil: Regularly check the engine oil level using the dipstick. If the oil level is low, refill it to the recommended level.
  3. Adjust the Idle Setting: Check the idle setting and adjust it to the proper level as per the manufacturer’s instructions. This adjustment can usually be done easily, ensuring your engine operates efficiently without overheating!

5. Malfunctioning Drive Belt

The most common issues relating to a malfunctioning drive belt include inadequate tension and worn-out belts that may affect the operation of the mower deck and other attached implements.

The machine, equipped with a 24HP Kawasaki 726cc 2-cyl gasoline engine and hydrostatic transmission, is designed for a range of outdoor chores. A drive belt in good condition is crucial for the effective operation of the mower deck, PTO (Power Take-off), and other mechanical aspects of this tractor. The belt ensures a seamless transmission of power from the engine to the mower deck and other attachments like snow blowers and blades. The drive belt, when malfunctioning, can cause issues like poor cutting performance, reduced efficiency in power transmission to the attachments, and in some cases, a complete halt in operation. The specifications of the truck, such as its mid PTO and electric clutch, play a part in how the drive belt functions and potentially, in the challenges that might arise. Moreover, the attachment of a 48″ or 54″ mid-mount mower deck requires a well-functioning drive belt to ensure optimal performance. If the belt is worn out or the tension is not adequate, it may slip or not transmit power efficiently, affecting the overall functionality and performance of the tractor.

How to Fix Malfunctioning Drive Belt:

  1. Inspect the Drive Belt: Check for wear, tear, or any damage. Look for loose sections or a belt that has slipped off the pulleys.
  2. Check Belt Tension: Ensure the belt has the right amount of tension. It should not be too tight or too loose. The correct tension ensures that the belt and pulleys move freely without any hindrance.
  3. Adjust or Replace: If the belt is loose, adjust the tension as per the manufacturer’s specifications. If the belt is worn out or damaged, replace it with a new one following the guidelines in the owner’s manual.
  4. Check Pulleys and Pathways: Ensure the pulleys are in good condition and the belt pathways are clear of debris.
  5. Test the Tractor: After making adjustments or replacements, test the tractor to ensure that the problem is resolved and the tractor operates smoothly.
  6. Regular Maintenance: Periodically inspect the drive belt, pulleys, and associated parts to prevent future issues. Replace the belt as per the maintenance schedule provided in the owner’s manual.

6. Fuel Gauge Malfunction

The most common issues relating to fuel gauge malfunction are faulty wiring or sensors, damage or wear on the gauge itself, and electrical issues possibly stemming from a faulty battery or broken wires.

The lawn mower, comes with a 24HP Kawasaki engine, hydrostatic transmission, and a fuel capacity of 4.4 gallons. It’s designed with an electrical system that includes a flywheel alternator, which regulates the charging system with 15 amps of power, alongside a 12-volt battery with 500 cold cranking amps. A malfunctioning fuel gauge can often be traced back to electrical issues such as a faulty battery or broken wires, which could disrupt the power supply to the fuel gauge, rendering it inoperative. The fuel gauge, being a critical component, helps in monitoring the fuel level, ensuring the lawn tractor doesn’t run out of fuel midway through a task. This malfunction could be due to damaged wiring or sensors responsible for reading the fuel levels. Over time, these wires or sensors may deteriorate or get damaged, leading to inaccurate fuel level readings on the gauge. Furthermore, the fuel gauge itself might show signs of wear or damage, which could also lead to inaccurate readings or total failure of the gauge.

How to Fix Fuel Gauge Malfunction:

  1. Inspect the Fuel Gauge: Regularly check for any signs of damage or wear on the gauge, as well as the connections and wiring leading to it.
  2. Check Electrical Connections: Inspect the battery, ensure it’s fully charged, and check for corroded terminals or broken wires that might be affecting the power supply to the fuel gauge.
  3. Clean and Secure Connections: Clean any corroded terminals and secure loose connections. If necessary, replace damaged wiring or sensors.
  4. Consult a Professional: If the issue persists, consider consulting a professional mechanic who specializes in lawn tractor repairs, to diagnose and fix the problem.
  5. Replace the Fuel Gauge: If the fuel gauge is found to be faulty, replace it with a new one to resolve the issue!

7. Difficulty in Steering

The most common issues causing difficulty in steering are worn or damaged steering components, loose connections, and hydraulic problems related to power steering.

The lawn truck is equipped with power steering, which should offer a smooth steering experience. However, like any mechanical component, wear and tear over time can lead to steering issues. The problem could be rooted in loose or damaged steering components, worn steering gears, or even issues with the hydraulic system powering the steering mechanism—especially since some owners have reported having to address hydraulic problems related to power steering multiple times. The X580’s mechanical system incorporates a two-wheel drive and a differential lock mechanical rear, which, if not well-maintained, could potentially contribute to steering problems. Additionally, issues with the hydrostatic transaxle, which gives this mower automotive-like automatic transmission, may also play a part in the difficulty in steering. Addressing these issues promptly is crucial—not only to ensure the longevity of your lawn tractor but also to prevent accidents that could arise from steering malfunctions.

How to Fix Difficulty in Steering:

  1. Inspect all steering components: Check for any signs of wear, damage, or loose connections.
  2. Check the hydraulic system: Ensure it’s adequately filled with hydraulic fluid and free from any leaks or blockages.
  3. Lubricate: Apply lubricant to all moving parts of the steering system.
  4. Replacement: Replace any worn or damaged parts immediately.
  5. Consider consulting a professional technician: It’s essential to address any steering issues promptly to ensure the safety and functionality of your lawn tractor!

If you don’t already own one, should you buy it?

The X580 truck, despite its robust and efficient 24HP Kawasaki engine, hydrostatic transmission, and a 54-inch cutting deck, has some drawbacks that might make you reconsider the purchase. Common issues include engine starting failure, engine stalling or rough running, imperfect cutting, abnormal heating, malfunctioning drive belt, fuel gauge malfunction, and difficulty in steering. Particularly, engine starting problems could be a setback when you have a large lawn waiting to be mowed. These challenges often stem from several mechanical issues such as a depleted fuel tank, faulty or dirty spark plugs, a dead battery, or a clogged fuel filter.

According to a review on Haute Life Hub, the X580 offers a powerful iTorque™ power system, easy-to-use Twin Touch™ hydrostatic transmission, and the convenience of hydraulic lift and power steering. However, it also mentions that the mower deck may not cut evenly on uneven terrain.

On the brighter side, users have appreciated the X580 for its iTorque™ power system, easy-to-use Twin Touch™ hydrostatic transmission, and the convenience of hydraulic lift and power steering, which are significant for reducing operator fatigue and ensuring smooth operations.

However, there’s a notable concern regarding the price. It was priced at $7,299 in 2017, indicating a position in a higher price bracket which might not align with everyone’s budget especially when considering the common problems associated with this lawn tractor.

As an alternate, you might want to consider models from competing brands. For example, the Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series could be a viable option, as it is often compared with John Deere’s X500 series in terms of performance and price but may offer a different set of features and possibly fewer common operational problems.

In summary, if you’re prepared for the possibility of addressing some common mechanical issues and the price point fits within your budget, this workhorse could be a solid investment for large lawn maintenance tasks. Nonetheless, exploring alternatives from other reputable brands might lead to finding a tractor that better suits your needs and possibly at a more affordable price point.

Why trust Igra World?

In the extensive process of creating a troubleshooting guide for this tractor, the seasoned mechanics and meticulous editors at Igra World delved deep into identifying common issues such as engine failure, overheating, and hydrostatic transmission issues. They prepared a comprehensive list of troubleshooting scenarios, which was meticulously documented—highlighting the malfunctions and their respective solutions. Each problem was thoroughly evaluated, with practical solutions defined to address the quirks of this model. Despite its premium promise, the X580 showed signs of engine and transmission malfunctioning—issues frequently encountered by many users. This guide was adapted continuously to include firsthand experiences and feedback, ensuring a top-notch, user-centric resource for resolving the common and the not-so-common problems. In retrospect, while this lawn truck boasted superior features, our extensive delve into its common issues and the rigorous process to document solutions revealed a different narrative. The X580 model, though robust in design, required users to frequently resolve various malfunctions—a journey of discovery that enhanced our troubleshooting guide, but left a bittersweet taste regarding the model’s reliability.

About Jeff Henderson

Have a question regarding your lawn tractor? Igra World writer Jeff Henderson may have covered it already on this site, if not you can contact him at jeff.h@igra-world.com and (417) 414-5099 if you have an problem you can't find an answer to. Jeff is a part time tractor mechanic and landscaping company owner who lives in Springfield, Missouri. He has over 10 years of experience in tractor repair and small engine repair, and has worked with John Deere, Husqvarna, Toro, Troy Bilt, Cub Cadet and Kubota equipment.

Join the discussion